My flat-rate book came from a competitor: is it paying after drive time and callbacks?

Greymill AcademyUS5 min readReviewed Oct 202610 primary sourcesUK version

The short answer

Flat-rate prices only work if the hourly rate inside them is built from the hours your techs actually sell, not the hours you pay.

The takeaway. Build the hourly rate from billable hours, price each task as hours times that rate plus marked-up materials, and reprice the book whenever wages or supply prices move.

Play the interactive lesson

Written for plumbers, electricians, water heater and heat pump installers, drain and sewer shops, and small multi-trade firms serving homeowners and property managers, with Texas, California, Florida and New York in detail.

The short version

  1. Count the hours your techs actually sell.Efficiency is billable hours over paid hours. Drive time, supply house runs, callbacks and training are paid but never sold.
  2. Build your hourly rate from your costs.Break-even is burdened wage over efficiency, plus overhead over billable hours. For example, divide it by 0.80 for a 20% net margin.
  3. Price every task from that rate.Task hours times your rate, plus materials times your markup factor. Reprice the book whenever wages, overhead or supply prices move.

It is tempting to set flat rates by copying a competitor's book or picking a number that felt right. The problem is the hours your techs are paid for but never sell: drive time, supply house runs, callbacks and training. Build the hourly rate from billable hours, then build every task price from that rate.

The hourly rate

Cost per billable hour is the burdened wage divided by efficiency, plus overhead divided by billable hours. The burdened wage adds payroll taxes, workers' comp and benefits to the hourly wage. Efficiency is billable hours over paid hours, and it is the lever to work on.

A six-tech shop, worked through (indicative, as of Oct 2026)
Labor per billable hour: $41.60 burdened wage / 0.60 efficiency$69.33
Overhead per billable hour: $780,000 / 7,488 billable hours$104.17
Break-even per billable hour$173.50
Hourly rate for a 20% net margin$216.88

$173.50 / 0.80Six techs at $32.00 an hour with a 30% burden ($41.60), 2,080 paid hours each (12,480 in all) and 60% efficiency give 7,488 billable hours. The $780,000 of overhead covers trucks, fuel, insurance, office staff, software, rent, marketing and the owner's salary. At the unrounded rate, 7,488 hours bring in $1,623,960 against $519,168 of labor and $780,000 of overhead: $324,792 profit, 20.0%. Margin on marked-up materials comes on top.

From the hourly rate to the task price

A flat-rate task price is the task hours times the hourly rate, plus materials times your material markup factor.

A 40-gallon water heater swap (indicative, as of Oct 2026)
Labor: 3.5 hours x $216.88$759.08
Materials: $850 x 1.5 markup factor$1,275
Flat-rate price$2,034.08
Set in the price book at$2,034

$2,034.08, roundedRecheck the book whenever wages, overhead or supply house prices move.

Keep margin and markup apart: margin is profit over price, markup is profit over cost. For example, a 25% markup on cost is only a 20% margin on price, and a 1.5 material markup factor is a 50% markup but a 33% margin.

AvoidCopying a competitor's flat-rate book and never rechecking it.
Do this insteadBuilding the hourly rate from your own efficiency and overhead, pricing each task from it, and repricing when wages, overhead or supply house prices move.

Two shops paying the same wages can need very different rates, because efficiency and overhead decide what each sold hour has to carry.

Memberships and the trip charge

Price memberships from the labor cost per billable hour, and remember that what is left still has to cover overhead.

A $20 a month membership (indicative, as of Oct 2026)
Annual visit: 1.5 hours at $69.33$104
Parts$15
Left to cover overhead and profit (50.4%), before the repair discount$121
Membership income a year$240
From 500 members$60,500

500 x $121.00Steady revenue in the slow months, and first call on replacements.

The rule

A membership that promises free repairs may be a regulated product

Visits, priority dispatch and discounts are service agreements. A fixed-fee promise to repair a failed system may be a regulated service contract or home warranty: Texas residential service-contract providers register under chapter 1304 and keep required financial security, California home protection needs Department of Insurance licensing, Florida home warranties need OIR licensing, and New York service contracts need DFS registration. Bill repairs at the member discount unless you sell a registered or licensed provider's product. As of Oct 2026.

Tex. Occ. Code ch. 1304; Cal. Ins. Code sec. 12740; Fla. Stat. ch. 634, part II; N.Y. Ins. Law art. 79

The rule

Auto-renewing memberships

In California, an auto-renewing membership needs the customer's express consent and an annual reminder, and a member who joined online must be able to cancel online. New York has its own auto-renewal law, and Florida has notice rules for service contracts. The FTC click-to-cancel rule was vacated in July 2025, but ROSCA still requires clear terms, express consent and simple online cancellation of a recurring charge. Noncompliant charges risk refunds and unfair and deceptive practices claims. As of Oct 2026.

Cal. Bus. and Prof. Code secs. 17600 to 17606; N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law sec. 527-a; 15 U.S.C. secs. 8401 to 8405

State your trip charge before dispatch and say what it covers. If your policy is to credit it against approved work, put that policy in writing.

Track your own average ticket, close rate on options, callbacks, efficiency, membership count and renewal rate. An industry benchmark is only worth using with a named, dated source behind it.

Asked in Greymill

Example question and answer from Cash & Profit
You
Copied a competitor's flat-rate book. It's built on $165 an hour. Six techs at $32 an hour, 2,080 paid hours each, about 30% burden. We sell maybe 60% of paid hours. Overhead is $780k a year. I want 20% net. Does $165 work?
Cash & Profit
$165 is $8.50 short of break-even on every hour you sell.

Labor: $41.60 burdened wage / 0.60 efficiency = about $69.33
Overhead: $780,000 / 7,488 billable hours = about $104.17
Break-even: $173.50
For 20% net: $173.50 / 0.80 = about $216.88

Burdened wage is $32 plus 30% for payroll taxes, workers' comp and benefits. Billable hours are 6 techs x 2,080 paid hours x 60%.

Why the copied book fails: it carries another shop's efficiency and overhead. Yours decide what each sold hour must carry, including paid hours you never sell: drive time, supply house runs, callbacks, training.

Task prices: hours x rate, plus parts x markup factor. For example, a 3.5-hour water heater swap with $850 of parts at a 1.5 markup factor is about $2,034.

Reprice whenever wages or supply prices move. Want me to reprice your ten busiest tasks at $216.88?

Play this demo in the Academy

Ask it about your own business

Paste this into Greymill with your own figures, and Cash & Profit works it through for your business.

Your question

I run a plumbing, heating or electrical business in [state], in the US. I have [number] techs at [hourly wage] with a burden of about [percentage], each paid around [hours] a year, and I think we sell [percentage] of paid hours. Overhead is about [amount] a year and I want a [target] net margin. Work out my hourly rate, then reprice these tasks in my book: [task, hours, materials cost, markup factor].

Start free trialHow it works7 days free with every specialist. No card needed.

More for plumbing, heating and electrical in the US

Open the interactive lesson · Every plumbing, heating and electrical lesson · What Greymill knows about the trade

Sources

The primary sources behind this lesson, checked Oct 2026.

  1. Enrolled HB1560 (2021) sections 4.10 and 6.02 repeal and commence; section 4.12 legacy-security transition ended September 1, 2026 (Memberships, service contracts, auto-renewal and financing)
  2. Ins. Code sec. 12740 (Memberships, service contracts, auto-renewal and financing)
  3. ch. 634 part II (Memberships, service contracts, auto-renewal and financing)
  4. Ins. Law art. 79 (Memberships, service contracts, auto-renewal and financing)
  5. secs. 17600 to 17606 (Memberships, service contracts, auto-renewal and financing)
  6. 15 U.S.C. secs. 8401 to 8405 (Memberships, service contracts, auto-renewal and financing)
  7. sec. 7159.5 (Hard cases: money, CONTRACTS and people)
  8. Texas Occ. Code ch. 1304; TDLR provider registration and financial security (Hard cases: money, CONTRACTS and people)
  9. 12 C.F.R. 1026.4 (Hard cases: money, CONTRACTS and people)
  10. Lab. Code secs. 226.2, 510 (Hard cases: money, CONTRACTS and people)

Ready to try Greymill?

Sixteen specialists who already know your trade and your country, sharing one memory of your business.

7 days free with every specialist. No card needed.

Continue with GoogleTry the demo, no sign-up