Buying a restaurant or signing a lease without inheriting someone else's debts

Greymill AcademyUS5 min readReviewed Oct 20267 primary sourcesUK version

The short answer

The lease, vendor and purchase terms that sink restaurants, and the notices that stop a buyer inheriting the seller's unpaid sales tax.

The takeaway. Before signing, cap the personal guaranty, calendar every auto-renewal notice, and when buying, follow the state's tax clearance steps before paying, or the seller's sales tax becomes yours.

Play the interactive lesson

Written for owners of restaurants, cafes and coffee shops, bars, takeout and delivery kitchens, food trucks and bakeries with seating in the US, with state detail for California, Texas, New York and Florida.

The short version

  1. Cap the personal guaranty before signing.Limit it in amount and time, or ask for a good guy guaranty that ends when you return the keys with rent paid.
  2. Calendar every auto-renewal notice deadline.POS and processing contracts can auto-renew with early termination fees. Before you sign, find the notice deadline and put it in your calendar.
  3. Follow tax clearance steps before you pay.For example, New York's advance notice or California's clearance certificate. Skip them and the seller's unpaid sales tax can become yours.

Most restaurant contracts are written by the other side: the landlord, the POS company, the equipment lessor, the delivery app, the franchisor. When you buy a restaurant, you can also inherit the seller's unpaid sales tax along with the ovens. A handful of clauses and one notice do most of the damage.

Red flags in leases and vendor contracts

  • Unlimited personal guaranty on the lease: cap it in amount and time, or seek a 'good guy' guaranty that ends when the keys are returned with rent paid.
  • Uncapped CAM (common area maintenance) and operating expense pass-throughs: cap controllable increases and get audit rights.
  • No exclusive use clause in a shopping center: protect your cuisine or category.
  • A radius restriction: it can block a second unit nearby.
  • A relocation or demolition clause: require compensation for the build-out.
  • Delivery platform exclusivity with price parity: compare with your own ordering margin first.
  • POS or processing contracts that auto-renew with early termination fees: calendar the notice deadline.
  • An equipment lease with a hell-or-high-water clause: total the payments against buying.
  • A merchant cash advance with a confession of judgment or a personal guaranty of performance: have an attorney read it first.

Buying a restaurant: successor liability

The rule

Sales tax follows the business

California: withhold from the price until the seller produces a CDTFA tax clearance certificate. New York: notify the Tax Department on Form AU-196.10 at least 10 days before paying or taking possession, or the buyer is liable. Texas: withhold until a certificate of no tax due. Florida: the buyer is liable unless the seller provides a certificate. As of Oct 2026.

Cal. Rev. & Tax. Code 6811 and 6812; N.Y. Tax Law 1141(c); Tex. Tax Code 111.020; Fla. Stat. 213.758

Buying a Brooklyn restaurant for $400,000
Paid to the seller$365,000
Seller's unpaid sales tax, paid from escrow$35,000
Purchase price$400,000

The buyer filed Form AU-196.10 at least 10 days before closing, and the Tax Department reported $35,000 of the seller's unpaid sales tax, which escrow paid from the price. Without the notice the buyer could have inherited it. As of Oct 2026.

In California, bulk sale law also still covers restaurant asset sales: notice to creditors before the sale, through escrow (Com. Code 6101 and following), on top of the liquor license escrow. Owner-operated restaurants usually sell as an asset deal priced on seller's discretionary earnings (SDE) or on the equipment, lease and license, so have the attorney cover the purchase agreement, the bulk sale and the license transfer together.

AvoidSay you pay a multiple of a diner's $220,000 of SDE, then hire a manager to run it.
Do this insteadIn that example, take the $70,000 manager's salary out first, leaving $150,000 of earnings you actually buy, and price that off a dated broker survey or your own required payback, not a remembered multiple.

SDE includes the seller's own labor. If you will pay someone else to do that work, that salary is not profit you are buying.

Franchises

The rule

Franchise disclosure

The franchisor must give you the Franchise Disclosure Document at least 14 calendar days before you sign or pay. Financial performance representations appear only in Item 19. California and New York also require franchise registration. As of Oct 2026.

16 CFR 436.2; Cal. Corp. Code 31110; N.Y. Gen. Bus. Law 683

If a franchise salesperson tells you what stores take, ask where it is in Item 19. If it is not there, it should not have been said. Build your own model from current franchisees' figures, and have franchise counsel review it before you sign or pay.

Asked in Greymill

Example question and answer from Contracts & Disputes
You
Buying a restaurant in Brooklyn for $400,000. We close in a week and the seller wants the full price wired at closing. My broker says any sales tax the seller owes is their problem. Anything I'm missing?
Contracts & Disputes
You're missing the notice. File it with the Tax Department now and push the closing back, or the seller's unpaid sales tax can become yours.

The rule: in New York, file Form AU-196.10 at least 10 days before you pay or take possession, or you, the buyer, are liable (As of Oct 2026). A week is not enough.

How it protects you: the Tax Department can then report what the seller owes, and escrow can pay it from the price. Say it reports $35,000:
Tax paid from escrow: $35,000
To the seller: $365,000

On the lease: if you are taking it over, cap any personal guaranty (your own promise to cover the lease) in amount and time. Or ask for a good guy guaranty that ends when you return the keys with rent paid.

Paste the guaranty and renewal clauses here and I'll flag what to push back on.

Play this demo in the Academy

Ask it about your own business

Paste this into Greymill with your own figures, and Contracts & Disputes works it through for your business.

Your question

I run a restaurant, cafe or bar in [state], in the US. I am [signing a lease / renewing with [vendor] / buying a restaurant for [amount] with seller's discretionary earnings of [amount] / considering a franchise]. Here are the key terms: [paste the guaranty, CAM, exclusive use, radius, renewal and termination clauses]. Flag the red flags, list every notice deadline to calendar, and set out the tax clearance and transfer steps for my state, with the questions for my attorney.

Start free trialHow it works7 days free with every specialist. No card needed.

More for restaurants, cafes and bars in the US

Open the interactive lesson · Every restaurants, cafes and bars lesson · What Greymill knows about the trade

Sources

The primary sources behind this lesson, checked Oct 2026.

  1. Rev. & Tax. Code 6811, 6812 (Growth, buying, selling and franchise disclosure (fdd))
  2. Tax Code 111.020 (Growth, buying, selling and franchise disclosure (fdd))
  3. Fla. Stat. 213.758 (Growth, buying, selling and franchise disclosure (fdd))
  4. Com. Code 6101 and following (Growth, buying, selling and franchise disclosure (fdd))
  5. 16 CFR 436.2, 436.5(s) (Growth, buying, selling and franchise disclosure (fdd))
  6. Corp. Code 31110; NY Gen. Bus. Law 683 (Growth, buying, selling and franchise disclosure (fdd))
  7. Texas Labor Code 406.033 (Hard cases: insurance, growth and exit)

Ready to try Greymill?

Sixteen specialists who already know your trade and your country, sharing one memory of your business.

7 days free with every specialist. No card needed.

Continue with GoogleTry the demo, no sign-up