Paying negotiators on commission without falling below the minimum wage

Greymill AcademyUK4 min readReviewed Oct 20266 primary sourcesUS version

The short answer

Low basic pay plus commission can fail the minimum wage in a quiet month, and renewal-based commission has to be retired properly now renewals have gone.

The takeaway. Check every month's pay against the minimum wage floor for hours worked, pay commission on fee income received, and change commission terms only by agreement.

Play the interactive lesson

Written for portfolio landlords, letting and managing agents, HMO operators and short-let operators in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.

The short version

  1. Work out each person's floor for the month.Hours worked times their minimum wage rate. For example, 40 hours a week is about 173 hours a month.
  2. Top up any month that falls short.Each pay period is tested on its own, not the year's average. An unpaid top-up is arrears HMRC can recover, with a penalty.
  3. Change commission terms only by agreement.Pay commission on fee income received. Retire renewal commission with notice and consultation, after advice from an employment solicitor.

Lettings agencies have long paid negotiators and property managers a low basic salary topped up with commission. That works in a busy month. In a quiet month the total can fall below the minimum wage for the hours worked, and the shortfall becomes a debt the agency owes.

The test runs pay period by pay period, not over the year: pay must be at or above the National Minimum Wage for every hour, averaged over each pay reference period. The National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over is £12.71 an hour from 1 April 2026. An unpaid top-up is arrears HMRC can recover, with a penalty. As of Oct 2026.

Hannah's quiet month: a negotiator aged 24 on 40 hours a week
Basic pay£1,400
Commission in a quiet month£500
Pay for the month£1,900
Top-up the agency must pay that month£303.07

£2,203.07 floor (40 x 52 / 12 hours x £12.71) - £1,900That is 173.33 hours a month. In a month with £1,100 of commission (£2,500 in all) she is above the floor. Model the worst month, not the average.

Retiring renewal commission

With no fixed terms in England since 1 May 2026, commission tied to renewals has no renewal events left to pay on. Pay commission on fee income received, not rent agreed, and claw back only if the contract says so. Retire renewal-based commission with notice and consultation, because changing contractual pay without agreement is a breach. Take advice from an employment solicitor before you change the terms.

Contractors and lone working

  • Use Gas Safe registered engineers for gas work, and check the work categories on their card.
  • Use electricians in a competent person scheme for electrical reports, and keep each certificate against its property.
  • A "self-employed" handyman working set hours for one agency may be a worker or employee under the usual control and substitution tests.
  • Lone viewings and inspections of empty properties need a risk assessment, a logged check-in routine and verification of applicants (Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974).
  • Employers' liability insurance is compulsory once you have employees.
AvoidFor example, setting a £1,400 basic because commission averages comfortably above the floor across the year.
Do this insteadChecking each pay reference period on its own, and topping up in the month pay falls short.

The minimum wage is averaged over each pay reference period, not the year, so one quiet month creates arrears.

No qualification is required by law to work as a letting agent in England, because regulation of property agents is still a proposal. Propertymark requires qualifications of its members, and Rent Smart Wales requires approved training for a licence.

Asked in Greymill

Example question and answer from Staff & HR
You
Hiring a negotiator aged 24, 40 hours a week. Thinking £1,400 a month basic plus commission. Commission should average about £1,000 a month, maybe £500 in a quiet one. Over the year that is well above minimum wage. Sound?
Staff & HR
Not in a quiet month. That month you would owe a £303.07 top-up.

Hours: 40 a week is about 173.33 a month
Floor at £12.71 an hour: £2,203.07 a month
Average month: £1,400 + £1,000 = £2,400, above the floor
Quiet month: £1,400 + £500 = £1,900, so £303.07 short

£12.71 is the National Living Wage for workers aged 21 and over, from 1 April 2026 (As of Oct 2026).

Why the year doesn't help: the test runs pay period by pay period, not across the year. Leave a top-up unpaid and HMRC can recover the arrears, with a penalty.

So plan pay around the worst month, not the average. Ready for a commission plan paid on fee income received, with a monthly floor check built in?

Play this demo in the Academy

Ask it about your own business

Paste this into Greymill with your own figures, and Staff & HR works it through for your business.

Your question

I run a property management business in the UK. I employ [number] negotiators and property managers on [basic salary] plus commission on [what it is paid on], working [hours] a week, aged [ages]. Check each role's worst recent month against the minimum wage floor, show any top-up we owe, and draft a new commission plan paid on fee income received, with a consultation plan for retiring renewal commission.

Start free trialHow it works7 days free with every specialist. No card needed.

More for property management and rentals in the UK

Open the interactive lesson · Every property management and rentals lesson · What Greymill knows about the trade

Sources

The primary sources behind this lesson, checked Oct 2026.

  1. National Minimum Wage Regulations 2015 regs 7, 9, 10 (People: agency roles, qualifications)
  2. ERA 1996 s13 (deductions) (People: agency roles, qualifications)
  3. s19 (People: agency roles, qualifications)
  4. reg 3(3) (People: agency roles, qualifications)
  5. s1 (People: agency roles, qualifications)
  6. regs 3, 4 (People: agency roles, qualifications)

Ready to try Greymill?

Sixteen specialists who already know your trade and your country, sharing one memory of your business.

7 days free with every specialist. No card needed.

Continue with GoogleTry the demo, no sign-up